Add Your Review

Thanks for visiting Brotherhood of Thieves. We'd love to have your feedback!

Nantucket, MA

Don't remember the name of your dish? Find it on our menu!

Which dish or item did you try?

You are submitting your information to Brotherhood of Thieves and Popmenu, which powers this site and is sponsoring this giveaway. By submitting, you agree to the Popmenu and .

Our Latest Reviews

Mmr4647 1 day ago

Dayboat Fried Cod

As always, we had great food, the fish fry was good, and outside dining was wonderful

Robin 27 days ago

Spicy Fried Shrimp & Calamari

Happy hour is the best deal on the island!

Karen about 1 month ago

The Arty

Amazing burger, great flavor!

Elizabeth about 1 month ago

Lobster Bisque with Pastry

This is the dish I think about all year. It was as good as always. Love the pastry on the top. Sat outside at a nice table with an umbrella. It was a perfect spot!

Amanda 2 months ago

Arty's Sliders

Awesome food

Nate 2 months ago

Broho Nachos

Best nachos on the island. They were really big though... could totally be a whole meal

Darcy 2 months ago

Fish & Chips

Without a doubt, the best fish and chips I've ever had! Will be back in May and you are our first stop after we check in to the hotel.

Pietro 3 months ago


Amazing milkshake, the best I have had in Nantucket! Strong flavor and felt light afterwards. Definitely recommend.

91watson 3 months ago

Burger Your Way

The burger was perfectly cooked, and the sides that came with it were also very great, especially the curly fries. The pickles were also very tasty. Also it was great presentation!

Agregoire73 3 months ago

Crispy Chicken Sandwich

very tasty sandwich. the chicken was amazing.

Matthew 3 months ago

Broho Nachos

Awesomeness! Have to be the best nachos I've ever had! We crushed them in minutes.

Dianetomas61 3 months ago

Lobster Bisque with Pastry

Wonderful lunch as always. Really enjoyed the calamari and lobster bisque and codfish sandwich! The peach bourbon smash was out of this world !

Brookesmith 3 months ago

Fried Green Tomato BLTA

Best restaurant. Loved the food it was delicious and great space. Great service.

Julialg13 3 months ago

Broho Nachos

I always get these and they are the best nachos I have ever have! Love them

Veronica 13 days ago

Cisco Burger

The best burger I have ever eaten!!!! Thank you!!!

Donald about 1 month ago

Grilled Prosciutto Cotto and Three Cheeses

Great take on the grilled ham and cheese sandwich! The three cheeses blend into a flavorful delight! This is a must for the ham and cheese lovers!

Jg4114 about 1 month ago

Gochujang Cauliflower

Loved it so much, ordered it 3 times over 2 days this past weekend. Love the happy hour menu and the terrific staff. Too bad, we live 3.5 hours and a ferry boat away from this place, or we'd be there every night.

Theo 2 months ago

Broho Nachos

Best nachos anywhere. Make sure you're hungry it's enormous. Feeds 4 🤙🏽

Ttorres723 2 months ago

Scallops & Bacon

Scallops cooked perfect, bacon nice and crunchy and the mustard sauce is an amazing touch. Well made

Nate 2 months ago

Cisco Burger

So good would totally recommend. It's was a lot bigger than expected but still really good. The servers were really nice

Pietro 3 months ago


Amazing dessert, definitely recommend! Perfect balance of flavors & definitely something to try

Susang646 3 months ago

Blondie of Thieves

This blondie was perfect for our family! The cookie and the vanilla ice cream was great together.perfect ways to top off the night

Ellag9335 3 months ago

Chocolate Mousse

The chocolate mousse was very tasty. The whipped cream that came with it was also very delicious!The presentation was immaculate and made you want to eat it up! Overall very yummy!

Lawkell439 3 months ago

Cisco Burger

Great burger.. fun atmosphere friendly attentive service. A must try on Nantucket

Sgreyeyes 3 months ago

Autumn Bruschetta

The bruschetta was amazing. Light and a good mix of flavors. I'll order extra marinated onions next time though. Two very enthusiastic thumbs up 👍🏼👍🏼

Danielamdiaz4 3 months ago

Broho Nachos

A great restaurant with one of the best nachos around! They're so good, I love them! I definitely recommend coming here and trying their nachos! :)

Brookesmith2002 3 months ago

Macaroni & Cheese - Cheeto's Crust

I love this restaurant. It was incredible. Best Mac and cheese I've ever had. Great scenery.

Delanceygracegaito 3 months ago

Broho Nachos

The most bang for your buck! Been ordering this dish religiously since the first time I tried it a few years ago. Definitely one of my favorite things on the menu! Although it's listed as an appetizer, it is definitely enough food to be a full meal for 2+ people! Definitely recommend to anyone looking to try something new.


September 2020:
Carol, Stroud's BBQ
Daytona Beach Shores, FL

August 2020:
Jo-El, Mick's All American
Mount Joy, PA 

July 2020:
Bronson, Los Dos Potrillos 

June 2020:
Elish, Crump's Landing
Homosassa, FL

May 2020:
Carlson, Papi Grande's Mexican
Amherst, NY

April 2020:
Sommer, Little Calf Creamery 
Thousand Oaks, CA

March 2020:
Theresa, Woody's Crab House
North East, MD

February 2020:
Maria, The Rustik Fork
Riverside, CA

January 2020:
Marsha, Stefano's Restaurant
Florence, SC

December 2019:
Alma, Karai Ramen Bistro
Jacksonville, FL

November 2019:
Courtney, Axe & Arrow
Seattle, WA

October 2019:
Andy, Backwoods Brewing Co.
Portland, OR

September 2019:
Amanda, Home Restaurant
Los Angeles, CA

August 2019:
Jennifer, Mark's City Grill
Columbus, GA

July 2019:
Rebecca, Frank Gourmet
Buffalo, NY

June 2019:
Donna, Dino's Sports Bar
Cape Cod, MA

May 2019:
Karen, This Little Pig
Amherst, NY

April 2019:
Alicia, Plant Based Pizzeria
Atlanta, GA