New Appetizer Special!

The Brotherhood of Thieves, established in 1972 by Arthur Krause, is a restaurant and bar in Nantucket, Massachusetts with three unique dining areas: downstairs, a rustic 1840's whaling bar, upstairs, a more traditional dining room perfect for private parties, and outside, a patio and biergarten showcasing local Nantucket beer, wine, and spirits. Our mission is to provide quality food in a family friendly environment, using the freshest, most local, organic, and natural ingredients. We do this in the belief these qualities will offer the best dining experience and will compliment our careful consideration of a sustainable environment. Read More